Wednesday, February 4, 2015

Problems with Social Justice?

so·cial jus·tice
noun
1.      justice in terms of the distribution of wealth, opportunities, and privileges within a society.

The word that catches my curiosity most is, “opportunities.”  Initially, it sounds nice and just to share everything, to have no one person or people better-off than another.  Why should anyone?  After all, we are all part of this world, this place that was here long before any one of us were here.  But, is this viable?  Did anything or person take opportunities away?  To me, it makes sense that all of us, as citizens of Planet Earth had the opportunities, and some of us chose not to.  In other words, not everyone wants to live up to an opportunity or possibility.

Social justice exists when “all people share a common humanity and therefore have a right to equitable treatment, support for their human rights, and a fair allocation of community resources.”  And, “equal opportunity" and similar phrases such as "personal responsibility" have been used to diminish the prospective for realizing social justice by justifying enormous inequalities in modern society.”  In other words, if a responsibility or opportunity is to be met, the only issue is not that it is there or offered to all equally, but that people must use that opportunity.  This is where I ask the question—do people really want equality?  Change is not a passive thing, change won’t knock on one’s door one day and announce its presence—it must be worked for.  I am also saying that if someone tries to ignore change, it will happen. It’s like teeth—the teeth will rot out—some change will come whether one likes it or not. (1)

There is the idea that some inequalities are unjust and simply not fair to those who they are imposed upon (which opens up a whole new batch of discussions) and should be lifted off of them.  If a society lifts burdens off of people, does this not create a whole new version of social equality?  Does it ever end?  If not, is the answer to the endless cycle of social “equality” actually to do nothing?  It just does not feel fair.

(1)   http://gjs.appstate.edu/social-justice-and-human-rights/what-social-justice


No comments:

Post a Comment